Magnolia Bakery Banana Pudding Recipe

26 comments

Magnolia Bakery may be known for its different cupcakes and cakes, but many people agree that Magnolia Bakery banana pudding is the best product sold in the bakery.

Magnolia Bakery Banana Pudding

If you’ve ever been to New York, the chances are you’ve probably tried their banana pudding and know that it’s the real deal. The bakery has locations in Chicago and LA as well, but if you live a long way from these locations, you probably can’t enjoy their one-of-a-kind banana pudding as often as you want.

Of course, you can have it delivered to your door, but it’ll cost you a lot. Luckily, Magnolia Bakery has released the original recipe for its famous banana pudding, so you can now make it in your own home for way less money.

And don’t worry about the ingredients. They are quite simple so you can find them easily.

Wouldn’t it be great if you can gather your family or friends so you can all enjoy this creamy goodness together?

Here’s everything you need to know to make homemade Magnolia Bakery banana pudding that tastes just as good as the original.

How to Make Magnolia Bakery Banana Pudding

The recipe has no weird ingredients – vanilla wafers, pudding, sweetened condensed milk, bananas, and cream. The preparation is super easy, and the most difficult part is when you have to wait for four to eight hours until the pudding chills in the fridge.

Can you make it that long? Well, for a dessert that delicious, anyone can. The reason why you shouldn’t serve the pudding too soon and wait for at least four hours is to give the ingredients and flavors a chance to blend together in the fridge into one soft and delicious creamy goodness. Eight hours is the maximum time to let the pudding set in the fridge.

But, make sure you serve it within 8 hours because the bananas might oxidize and turn brown. However, there are some tips to prevent them from browning too quickly. Buy unripe bananas that are slightly green and brush them with the juice of lemon, orange, apple, or pineapple. In this way, you will slow down the process of browning.

Another thing to do to prevent them from browning too fast is to rinse them with club soda. And, don’t forget to keep your bananas airtight.

Also, if you choose to top the pudding with banana slices, do it right before serving for best preservation.

If you want to get the original taste of the dessert, don’t use low sugar or low fat versions of the ingredients. This is crucial for the success of your homemade Magnolia Bakery banana pudding. So, use regular whipping cream, pudding mix, Nilla wafers, and sweetened condensed milk.

Here are all the ingredients and the right amounts necessary to make the best banana pudding according to the Magnolia Bakery’s original recipe.

Magnolia Bakery Banana Pudding Recipe

4 from 100 votes
Recipe by Laura Ritterman Course: DessertsCuisine: AmericanDifficulty: Easy
Servings

15

servings
Prep time

15

minutes
Calories

220

kcal
Total time

15

minutes

If you’ve ever been to Magnolia bakery, it’s highly likely you’ve bought their banana pudding. Bring the taste of Magnolia into your kitchen today.

Ingredients

  • 1 1/2 cups of ice cold water

  • 1 can sweetened condensed milk, (14 oz.)

  • 3 cups heavy cream

  • 1 box vanilla instant pudding mix (3.4 oz.)

  • 1 box Nilla Wafers, (12 oz.)

  • 4 cups banana slices

Directions

  • Beat together the water and condensed milk in a large bowl for two minutes to make sure they are well combined.
  • Stir in the pudding mix and continue beating for two more minutes.
  • Cover and store it in the fridge for at least three to four hours to let the pudding set. Otherwise, it can become watery.
  • Whip the heavy cream in a large bowl until it makes stiff peaks. Carefully fold the whipped cream into the pudding mixture.
  • You can make the dessert in a large glass bowl, 9×13 baking pan, or in individual portions using fancy glasses, paper containers, or china cups. The options are endless. If you don’t want to spend time making it in separate containers, use a large baking pan or glass bowl.
  • Cover the bottom of the container with 1/3 of the NIlla wafers, and don’t worry if they overlap.
  • Spread a layer of banana slices which should be 1/3 of the whole amount.
  • Layer 1/3 of the pudding mixture.
  • Do this twice more until there’s no more NIlla wafers, bananas, and pudding mixture.
  • Cover tightly and garnish with wafer crumbs or additional wafers on top.
  • Store it in the fridge for 4 to 8 hours to let the pudding set.
  • If you like to garnish with banana slices, wait to add them right before serving.
  • Enjoy.

Like this recipe?

Follow us @recipefairy on Pinterest

Can You Make Magnolia Bakery Banana Pudding Ahead of Time?

Not only that you can make it ahead of time, but you need to make it ahead of time. The pudding mixture needs to spend some time in the fridge so that it can thicken properly.

Therefore, you can start making the dessert one or two nights before you plan to consume it, or in the morning and serve it in the evening. However, the assembly of the banana pudding shouldn’t be done more than 8 hours in advance.

As soon as your homemade dessert is assembled with the NIlla wafers, you can eat it within four to eight hours. The reason why it needs to stay at least 4 hours in the fridge is to get the right texture and firmness, and to soften the Nilla Wafers.

If it stays longer than 8 hours, it can become soggy and the bananas can turn brown.

Conclusion

Is there a person who doesn’t like Magnolia Bakery banana pudding? Yes, only the ones that still haven’t got a chance to go to New York or the few other locations of the bakery and order this heavenly dessert.

Luckily, the bakery has shared the original recipe for its popular banana pudding so that everyone can make it in their own homes no matter where they live. The recipe requires simple and inexpensive ingredients, and the preparation is easy, so nothing is really stopping you from making this dessert today.

Gather your family or friends and give them one of the best creamy desserts they have ever tried. We’re sure they will love it just like anyone else that has tried Magnolia Bakery banana pudding.

26 Comments

  1. Jenny Stafford

    Love Banana Pudding!!! Thank You!!!

  2. Tammy Catterton

    It is top if rate 1 -5 it is a 5 thanks

  3. Wanda Tracey

    My husband will freak when I make this! He loves anything banana and this looks so decadent.

  4. Wanda Tracey

    I rate this recipe as a 5 star!

  5. Aubrey Daniels

    I can’t wait to make this!

  6. Sandra Watts

    That looks so good! 5 stars!

  7. Tammy Liscio

    Big 5 stars

  8. Looks like a 5 star experience

  9. Jeffrey Smead

    YUMMMMMM! LOOKS DELICIOUS

  10. Angie Benton

    Good so good 5 stars

    • Can I put the pudding mixture in the fridge overnight? I got so excited I’m trying this recipe now at 9pm but I can’t continue at midnight……🙄😂

  11. Johanna Newman

    Great recipe 5 Stars ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

  12. Julia Wilkie

    This looks yummy!

  13. Sarah Miller

    looks so good

  14. 5 stars

  15. Greg Nelson

    Looks like a 5-star recipe.

  16. Catherine Cole

    Definitely making this really soon just need to get ingredients -5 stars

  17. Melissa Outland

    I have never used sweetened condensed milk but I might try it. I do however always use regular pudding instead of instant. My grandmother made excellent pudding.

  18. Susan West

    I’ll give it a five!

  19. Shannon Peterson

    Delicious banana pudding. Very creamy and smoothe and bursting with delicious banana flavor ! I give it 5 stars and two thumbs up .

  20. I rate this a 5 out of 5!

  21. Randy Schuch

    My son goes bananas over banana pudding. I rate this recipe right up with the great ones, 5 Stars.

  22. Cheryll Powning

    Sounds amazing. Will be making as soon as I can!

  23. Tom Bellamy

    I love banana pudding!

  24. This recipe is amazing but I was not able to get my heavy whipping cream to whip. So I was going to use Cool Whip is that OK and how much can I use?

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*