Best Creamy Mashed Potatoes Recipe


There is not a single occasion that can be celebrated without a bowl of mash potatoes on the table. Even when I plan to replace it with some other side meal, my family always pushes me to make them a creamy mash potato bowl, for all the right reasons. Though there are countless ways to enjoy creamy mashed potatoes, the recipe I am going to share here today is my personal favorite.

Do you want to know why? Because it is full of nourishing nutrients. Even when you don’t serve it with a heavy meal, this mashed potato is enough to fulfil all your energy needs.

Creamy Mashed Potatoes Recipe

We will get to the recipe in a bit! Since it is super simple, we will first discuss the ingredients of the recipe.

There are basic ingredients that are essential for both the taste and texture of the mash potatoes. Then there can be some add-ons, and their use completely depends on your personal preferences.

I would recommend keeping it simple and easy. I have only used some salt to season the mash potatoes, but you can also add a pinch of ground black pepper to enhance its taste. Similarly, ground white pepper in a small amount can also infuse good flavors in the mash potatoes.  

What kind of potatoes are best for mashed potatoes?

Ok! Let’s start with the very basic and essential ingredient of mash potato, the Potatoes! Since there are several options to select from, people usually ask me which potato should they use to make mash potatoes. Well, they all can yield flavorsome results, whether it’s the red, gold, Yukon gold or Russet potatoes, etc. You will find their mash equally delicious.

However, there is a slight difference in the texture and amount of starch among the different kinds of potatoes.  

To get the fluffiest and creamiest mash potato I always recommend the classic russet potatoes! They belong to the true potato family and carry a lesser amount of starch compared to other types. They do not carry that mildly sweet taste, which some types of potatoes have. Moreover, the color of their flesh is perfect for giving your mash potato that tempting mild yellow creamy look.

How To Make Creamy Mashed Potatoes?

The mash potato we are going to make today is known for its unique garlicky flavor, and I bet you will all love the taste and aroma of it. I start with the boiling of the potatoes. But before that it is better to prepare them well for this step.

Often people directly boil the potatoes in a pot full of water, which makes the peeling and mashing difficult after boiling. It will be convenient if we first wash the potatoes well, then peel them and dice into quarters. Now add these pieces to the boiling water and let them cook until the potatoes are tender and soft. You can use a pinch of salt or more to add flavor to the boiling potatoes.

Once the potatoes are boiled, immediately strain and leave them in a colander. Just for 2-5 minutes, so that all the excess liquid is released out of the potatoes. Now that they are dry, you can transfer them to a large bowl or shallow tray in which you can easily mash them. Since you have boiled the pieces of potatoes, you can easily mash them using a fork. But for more convenience and to get a silky-smooth texture, you can use a ricer as well.

Make sure to rice the potatoes while they are hot; this practice will yield smoother mash potatoes. When all the potatoes are mashed, you can start adding other ingredients of the recipe. And while you do so, make sure to continuously mix the potatoes and avoid the lumps. The only hot liquid is added to the mash potatoes because cold milk, butter, or cream can again make the mash a bit lumpy in texture.

There are a few important points that we must keep in mind. First is to avoid over-mashing then to quickly work on the potatoes to keep them fresh and make a lump-free mash potato.

What to add to mashed potatoes?

  • I usually use cream cheese to increase the nutritional value of this meal and to give it a creamier texture.
  • Then you can try roasted garlic paste for a soothing and aromatic taste. For a unique color and flavor, adding pesto to the mashed potatoes is another good option.
  • If you can’t get your hands-on roasted garlic or any garlic paste, then garlic powder is another good option to season the mashed potatoes.
  • To make it richer, add some shredded cheddar cheese while the mashed potato is still hot and let it melt well. Similarly, you can also add gouda or goat cheese.

Creamy Mashed Potatoes Recipe

4 from 13 votes
Recipe by Laura Ritterman Course: SidesCuisine: AmericanDifficulty: Easy


Prep time


Cooking time



You’re going to love this recipe for the creamiest mashed potatoes. It’s a wonderful side dish to accompany any main. With only 6 ingredients you can be on your way to enjoying this dish in only 35 minutes flat. This dish can serve 6 people in total.


  • 3 pounds 3 russet potatoes, peeled and quartered

  • 3/4 cup 3/4 sour cream

  • 1 stick 2 tbsp butter

  • 6 garlic cloves, peeled and smashed

  • 3/4 cup 3/4 heavy cream, warm

  • Salt to taste


  • Add the butter stick to a small saucepan and place it over low heat.
  • Let it melt in the pan then stir in smash garlic and sauté for 15 minutes.
  • Now remove the garlic pieces from the butter and keep it warm.
  • Now fill a suitable cooking pot with water and add a tsp of salt into it.
  • Place this water pot over medium-high heat and let it boil first.
  • Add the potatoes to the water and let them cook on a simmer for 20 minutes until they get tender inside out.
  • Drain the potatoes pieces in a colander and allow all the moisture to release out of them.
  • Use the paper towel as well to pat dry the potato pieces.
  • Place a large glass bowl on the working surface and hold the ricer above it.
  • Pass the potatoes from the ricer and add their mash to the glass bowl.
  • Add melted garlic butter, salt, warm cream, and sour cream to the potato mash.
  • Blend these ingredients well using a hand mixer until well incorporated.
  • Adjust seasoning salt or black pepper if desired.
  • Garnish with your favorite herbs.
  • Enjoy!


  • Transfer to serving the dish. Melt remaining butter and pour over potatoes. Sprinkle with paprika and chopped parsley.

Like this recipe?

Follow us @recipefairy on Pinterest


And that’s how you can make a finger-licking delicious mash potato right in your kitchen. With this recipe, you can keep it ready to serve along with your favorite steak and entrees. So, try this garlicky and creamy mash potatoes recipe, and do not forget to write us back and leave your valuable feedback. 


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *