A pie iron is an incredibly useful cooking device for everyone who enjoys camping. It allows you to cook all kinds of camp meals over a campfire. From toasted sandwiches and pie/pizza dough to scones and muffins, a pie iron is ideal for a wide range of hand-held food items.
A good quality pie iron will last a lifetime without requiring too much cleaning or maintenance. And, it doesn’t have to cost you a lot.
We did our research and found the best and most affordable pie irons on the market. Things we have taken into consideration include construction, durability, special design features, handle length, etc.
Before we give you our list of best pie irons, let’s see what exactly pie iron is.
What’s a Pie Iron?
A pie iron is also known as a sandwich toaster, pudgy pie iron, toastie iron, jaffle iron, or snackwicher. It’s a cooking appliance that has 2 hinged concave, square or round, cast iron plates on long metal poles with heat-resistant handles.
It opens like a clamshell where you can put your food item. There are various shapes of this cooking appliance, but the standard shape can fit a slice of bread. Round pie irons, for example, are used for cooking hot dogs.
Best Pie Irons
Here are some of the best pie irons on the market. Check out their biggest advantages and disadvantages to decide which of them is the best option for you.
| 1 | Rome’s Double Pie Iron | Double iron to maximize cooking space. 28 inches. |
| 2 | Toas-Tite Handheld Pie Iron | 22-inch long handle |
| 3 | Coghlan’s Pie Iron | Affordable & durable |
| 4 | Palmer Pie Iron | Made from durable cast iron. Keeps ingredients sealed. |
| 5 | Camp Chief Pie Iron | Easy to use and clean with pen hinge |
1. Rome’s Double Pie Iron
Rome Industries manufactures high quality basic and specialty pie irons.
This one, in particular, is a double pie iron that provides more cooking space than the standard size.
So, you can use it to cook several pies or sandwiches at once.
It has beautiful wooden handles that make it stand out from the rest.
Pros
- Double Iron – Double iron to cook two calzones, sandwiches, fish, or quesadillas at once
- Exceptional Taste – Provides you with exceptional tasting food.
- Size – 28 inches in length
- Ridged – Ridged which allows pies and sandwiches to stay tightly sealed after cooking
Cons
- Handles – This pie iron doesn’t have detachable handles like most Rome’s pie irons which would’ve make cleaning and storing easier.
Verdict
The Rome Double Pie iron is relatively cheap and provides you with a solid pie iron. Value for money and the pros certainly outweigh the cons with this. See Price on Amazon
2. Toas-Tite Handheld Pie Iron
This great pie iron comes from an old, retro brand that has been manufacturing this cooking device since 1949.
It’s a universal pie iron that allows you to make pocket-style toasted sandwiches, desserts, and snacks like omelets, grilled cheese, pizza pockets, sweet s’mores, fruit pies, popcorn, etc.
It works in the fire pit, fireplace, campfires, BBQ grills, on gas, glass-top and electric stoves. This means that you can use it while camping or cooking in the kitchen or backyard.
Pros
- Handle – 22-inch long handle
- Versatile – Suitable for fire pits, BBQs, campfires, gas stoves, and ovens.
- Round design – The round design fits English muffins and removes crusts on bread
Cons
- Durability – Not made from cast iron but aluminum, which means reduced durability. It can warp from use, melt under overly high fire temperatures, and has an uneven heat distribution.
The Toas-Tite Handheld Pie Iron comes with 22 inch long handle and is all round a versatile option. Its round design uniquely positions it as a great selection. Just keep in mind it will be less durable than our number 1 recommended option due to being made from alluminium.
3. Coghlan’s Pie Iron
Here’s another pie iron coming from a reliable and reputable brand such as Coghlan’s. This manufacturer is known for their durable and easy-to-use cooking devices.
This model is made from durable cast iron so it can withstand the high heat of flames and coals. It’s great for making classic campfire pies, sandwiches, and grilling meat.
Ideal for toasties meat and even using for cooking dessert on an open-fire.
Most importantly, it’s an essential item for when you go camping or want to enjoy outdoor activities.
Pros
- Affordable – Worth the cost for the quality.
- Robust Durability – Buy knowing this will last
- Size – 27-inch long with wooden handles
- Options – Single broiler, double broiler, single, and double options available
Cons
- Worth Knowing – Even though it’s pre-seasoned, you should boost it with your own seasoning
- Maintenance – Requires careful maintenance
Coughlan’s Pie Iron comes with a 27 inch wooden handle and is a great selection for all round good quality. It does require some careful maintenance but certainly an option we you can rely on with an equally affordable price
4. Palmer Pie Iron
This is the most popular pie iron model from Palmer thanks to its high durability. That’s because of the high quality cast iron that can withstand a steady heat.
The square pie iron has ribs on the inside that seals the filling into two slices of bread. You can use it on a fireplace or outdoor grill.
Pros
- Affordable – Worth every cent.
- Highly Durable – Made from highly durable cast iron
- Size – 18 inches’ length but an extra-long option of 26 inches is available as well
- Ribs – Ribs in the inside that keep the ingredients tightly sealed
Cons
- Cleaning – A bit complicated to clean and handle as the hinge prevents the two pieces from separating.
The Palmer Pie Iron is an extremely popular option with durability being a key feature. Perfect for outdoor grills or using on a fireplace. This gets a thumbs up from us, although it would rank higher if we didn’t have to clean it after.
5. Camp Chief Pie Iron
This brand specializes in cast iron items such as this model of pie iron. It’s a sturdy pie iron with a size that can fit a standard white sandwich bread perfectly. If bigger, the bread won’t get sealed properly and the ingredients will fall our or ooze when you eat it.
You can use it to cook in the hot coals or over a campfire. It’s easy to use and maintain.
Pros
- Quality – High quality cast iron
- Easy to clean – Easy to use and clean with pen hinge.
- Size – 22-inch long pole
- Pre-seasoned
Cons
- Size – In comparison to the other options we’ve outlined, it’s a bit smaller than other pie irons on the list.
How to Use Your Pie Iron
Whether you are camping in the woods or cooking in your back yard, a pie iron is an ideal appliance for cooking or warming up your meal over a fire.
First, heat each half of the pie iron over an open fire. Once it’s warm enough, add your food item for cooking. Make sure it’s not too hot to prevent the food from burning. Generally, it takes around five minutes in a hot fire.
Place one half on a burn-resistant area and spray some oil in the inside pocket. Use avocado oil, grapeseed oil, or another oil with a high smoke point.
Put your dough or bread along the bottom, fill with your ingredients, and top with another piece of bread/dough. Coat or spray the top of the iron with some oil and close it with the fastener found at the handles.
Lay the pie iron over a bed of hot coals or embers to cook evenly. You can open it to check if your food is cooked, but it generally takes two to five minutes per side. When your food turns golden brown in color, it’s done.
Conclusion
A good quality pie iron will make your camping so much easier and fun. You can use it to cook everything from breakfast and lunch to dinner and dessert over an open fire.
We hope our list of five best pie irons will help you pick the right one for your needs.
