Soft Homemade Caramels

0 comments

✔ Updated · new candy recipe with step photos, exact firm-ball temperatures, a salted variation and a troubleshooting table

These soft caramels are the old-fashioned kind: cream, sugar and butter cooked slowly to firm ball, then cut into chewy squares and twisted up in wax paper. This is the caramel candy recipe I make for holiday boxes, with exact temperatures and a salted option.

How Do You Make Caramel Candy? (Quick Answer)

Warm 2 cups heavy cream with 1 stick butter and 1/2 teaspoon salt, and in a big heavy pan boil 2 cups sugar, 1 cup light corn syrup and 1/4 cup water to pale gold, 310°F. Off the heat, slowly stir in the warm cream, then cook, stirring, to 245 to 248°F (firm ball). Add vanilla, pour into a buttered parchment-lined 8-inch pan, cool 2 1/2 hours, cut into 64 squares and wrap in wax paper.

At a glance

245 to 248°FFirm ball
30 to 35 minOn the stove
2 1/2 hrTo set
64Caramels
80kcal each

The one tip that matters: The last 10 degrees are everything. Pull the caramel at 245°F for a soft, yielding chew, 248°F for a firmer caramel that holds its shape in a warm room. Above 250°F it starts heading toward toffee.

Why You'll Love These Caramels

  • Soft, chewy and smooth never grainy, never tooth-pulling, thanks to the corn syrup and a firm-ball finish.
  • Real caramel flavor because the sugar cooks to pale gold before the cream goes in, not just a sweet butter taste.
  • Exact temperatures in °F and °C plus the cold-water test as backup, so you can pick your chew.
  • One pan makes 64 enough for several gift boxes, and they keep for 2 weeks.
  • Salted or plain a pinch of flaky salt on top turns them into the salted caramels everyone fights over.
Soft homemade caramel squares with flaky salt, some wrapped in twisted wax paper, piled on a ceramic plate

What Makes Soft Caramels Work

A caramel is a sugar syrup with cream and butter cooked into it, and its texture is set almost entirely by the final temperature. Soft ball (235 to 240°F) gives a sauce that won't hold a shape, firm ball (245 to 250°F) gives a chewy candy you can cut and wrap, and hard crack (300°F) gives toffee.

Two things keep these caramels smooth. The corn syrup gets in the way of sugar crystals, so the candy stays glossy rather than sandy. And cooking the sugar to pale gold before the cream goes in builds real caramel flavor, instead of the plain sweet-butter taste you get when everything boils together from the start.

Ingredient Notes

Exact amounts are in the recipe card below.

  • Heavy cream: 36 to 40% fat for a rich, smooth chew. Half-and-half makes a thinner, less creamy caramel and is more likely to catch on the pan.
  • Unsalted butter: one stick, melted into the cream. Salted butter is fine; drop the fine salt to 1/4 teaspoon.
  • Granulated sugar: plain white sugar. For a deeper, molasses note, swap 1/2 cup for packed light brown sugar.
  • Light corn syrup: the insurance against grainy caramel. Golden syrup is the closest swap.
  • Vanilla extract: stirred in at the very end so the flavor isn't cooked off. Vanilla bean paste is lovely here.
  • Flaky sea salt: only for the salted version, scattered on top straight after pouring.

Step-by-Step Photos

Here's how it comes together. Exact amounts, times and temperatures are in the recipe card below.

Sugar syrup cooking to pale gold in a saucepan beside a pan of warm cream
1. Boil the sugar, corn syrup and water to pale gold, 310°F.
Pouring warm cream into hot sugar syrup as it foams up for caramels
2. Off the heat, stir in the warm cream slowly; it foams up high.
Caramel cooking to the firm-ball stage with the cold-water test in a bowl of ice water
3. Cook, stirring, to 245 to 248°F, the firm-ball stage.
Cutting a slab of set homemade caramel into squares and wrapping them in wax paper
4. Cool 2 1/2 hours, cut into 64 squares and wrap in wax paper.

Tips for Success

  • Test the thermometer in boiling water. The clip-on thermometer I use for candy should read 212°F (100°C) at sea level. Three degrees matters more with caramels than with almost any other candy: 3 degrees low and they ooze, 3 degrees high and they're chewy enough to pull a filling.
  • Adjust for altitude. Water boils at a lower temperature up high, so take about 1°F off the target for every 500 feet above sea level. At 5,000 feet, pull the caramel at 236 to 238°F.
  • Use the cold-water test too. Drop a little caramel into the bowl of ice water, wait 10 seconds and roll it between your fingers. Firm ball means it holds a shape but still squashes; if it flattens into a puddle, keep cooking.
  • Warm the cream first. Cold cream hitting 310°F syrup seizes it into a hard lump and sends foam over the rim. Warm cream slides in gently, and the caramel stays smooth.
  • Keep stirring once the cream is in. The milk solids in the cream can catch on the bottom and leave bitter brown flecks. I scrape the bottom every minute or so with a flat-ended silicone spatula, and I never leave the stove for the last 10 degrees.
  • Pick a dry day. Caramel pulls moisture from humid air and turns sticky and weepy. I make mine on crisp, dry days and let the slab cool uncovered so steam doesn't settle on top.
  • Respect the hot sugar. The syrup is over 300°F before the cream goes in and it foams up fast. No children stirring, long sleeves pushed up, pot handle turned in, and that bowl of ice water close enough to plunge a hand into.
  • Butter the knife and wrap the same day. A buttered knife or pizza wheel cuts clean squares, and I do the cutting and wrapping at the kitchen table with a stack of wax paper squares ready. Unwrapped caramels slowly flatten and stick together, so wrap them as soon as they're cut.

Soft and Chewy Homemade Caramels (Firm Ball, Wrapped)

Recipe by Laura Ritterman
0.0 from 0 votes
Course: Dessert, CandyCuisine: AmericanDifficulty: Easy
Servings

64

caramels
Prep time

15

minutes
Cooking time

35

minutes
Calories

80

kcal
Total time

3

hours 

20

minutes

Old-fashioned soft caramels made from heavy cream, sugar, corn syrup and butter, cooked slowly to the firm-ball stage (245 to 248°F), poured into an 8-inch pan, cooled, cut into squares and wrapped in wax paper. Chewy, buttery and smooth, with a flaky-salt option for salted caramels. Makes 64 pieces.

Ingredients

  • For the Caramels
  • 2 cups heavy cream

  • 1/2 cup unsalted butter (1 stick), cut into pieces, plus more for the pan

  • 1/2 teaspoon fine salt

  • 2 cups granulated sugar

  • 1 cup light corn syrup

  • 1/4 cup water

  • 1 1/2 teaspoons vanilla extract

  • For Salted Caramels (optional)
  • 1 teaspoon flaky sea salt

  • To Wrap
  • 64 wax paper, cut into 4 x 5-inch pieces

Directions

  • Line an 8-inch square pan with parchment, leaving an overhang on two sides, and butter the parchment. Set a bowl of ice water by the stove for safety and for the cold-water test. Check your candy thermometer in boiling water: it should read 212°F (100°C) at sea level.
  • Warm the cream, butter and salt in a small saucepan over low heat until the butter melts, then keep it warm. Hot cream added to hot sugar bubbles up far less than cold cream.
  • In a heavy 4-quart saucepan (the mixture triples in volume), stir the sugar, corn syrup and water over medium heat until the sugar dissolves. Stop stirring, clip on the thermometer, and boil until the syrup is pale gold and reads 310°F (154°C), 10 to 12 minutes.
    Sugar syrup cooking to pale gold in a saucepan beside a pan of warm cream
  • Take the pan off the heat. Slowly pour in the warm cream mixture while stirring with a long-handled spatula; it will hiss and foam up high, so pour in a steady stream and keep your hand clear of the steam.
    Pouring warm cream into hot sugar syrup as it foams up for caramels
  • Return the pan to medium heat and cook, stirring often and scraping the bottom, until the thermometer reads 245 to 248°F (118 to 120°C), the firm-ball stage, 15 to 20 minutes. Backup test: a spoonful dropped into ice water should form a firm ball that holds its shape but still gives when squeezed. Stir in the vanilla.
    Caramel cooking to the firm-ball stage with the cold-water test in a bowl of ice water
  • Pour the caramel into the lined pan without scraping the pot bottom (any scorched bits stay behind). Sprinkle with flaky salt if making salted caramels. Cool at room temperature, uncovered, until completely firm, at least 2 1/2 hours or overnight.
  • Lift the slab out by the parchment onto a cutting board. Cut it into 8 strips, then each strip into 8 pieces, with a long buttered knife or pizza wheel, wiping the blade as needed. Wrap each caramel in a piece of wax paper and twist the ends.
    Cutting a slab of set homemade caramel into squares and wrapping them in wax paper
  • Store the wrapped caramels in an airtight container at cool room temperature for up to 2 weeks, or refrigerate for 1 month and let them come to room temperature before eating.
Pinterest

Like this recipe?

Follow us @recipefairy on Pinterest

Pick Your Chew: Caramel Temperature Guide

The same pot of caramel becomes a different candy depending on where you stop. Here's how I decide, with the cold-water test for each stage.

Pull atCold-water testWhat you getBest for
238 to 240°F (114 to 116°C)Soft ball that flattens in your fingersSpoonable, very softCaramel sauce, dipping apples
245°F (118°C)Firm ball that squashes easilySoft, yielding chewEating fresh, cool kitchens
248°F (120°C)Firm ball that holds its shapeClassic chewy wrapped caramelGift boxes, warm rooms, shipping
252 to 255°F (122 to 124°C)Hard ball, barely givesFirm, long chewCaramel apples that need to cling
300°F (149°C)Hard threads that snapToffee, not caramelA different recipe entirely

Troubleshooting Homemade Caramels

Caramels are forgiving once you know what each problem means. Most batches can be fixed, and the rest become sauce.

ProblemLikely causeFix
Grainy or sandySugar crystallized: stirred while boiling, crystals on the pan sides, or no corn syrupDissolve sugar fully, brush the sides, don't stir until the cream goes in
Too soft, won't hold a squarePulled under 245°F, or thermometer reads highReboil with 2 tablespoons of cream to 246°F; calibrate the thermometer
Hard or tooth-pullingCooked past 250°FPull earlier next time; melt this batch into sauce with a splash of cream
Butter separated, oily surfaceHeat too high after the cream went in, or not stirredOff the heat, stir hard for 30 seconds; keep the heat at medium
Dark flecks, bitter tasteMilk solids scorched on the pan bottomUse a heavy pan, scrape the bottom often, don't pour the last scrapings into the mold
Sticky or weepy after a dayHumid kitchen, or stored unwrappedMake on a dry day, cool uncovered, wrap each piece in wax paper

Variations

Once the base recipe behaves, the pot takes flavor beautifully. These are the versions I come back to.

  • Salted caramels: 1 teaspoon of flaky sea salt over the top as soon as it's poured. This is the version that disappears first from our holiday boxes.
  • Chocolate-dipped caramels: chill the cut squares for 20 minutes, dip in melted dark chocolate and set on parchment with a flake of salt on top.
  • Vanilla bean caramels: split a vanilla bean into the cream as it warms and leave the seeds in; skip the extract.
  • Espresso caramels: dissolve 2 teaspoons of instant espresso powder in the warm cream.
  • Pecan caramels: scatter 1 cup of toasted chopped pecans over the pan before pouring the caramel, so every square has a nutty bottom.
  • Bourbon caramels: stir 1 tablespoon of bourbon in with the vanilla at the end.

Storage and Make-Ahead

Wrapped caramels keep for about 2 weeks in an airtight container at cool room temperature. Keep them away from the stove and out of the sun, or the squares slump and stick to their wrappers.

In the refrigerator they last a month; let them sit out for 20 minutes so they're soft again. For holiday gifting I make the slab up to a week ahead, wrap the squares, and box them the day they go out. They freeze for 3 months, wrapped and sealed in a bag; thaw them sealed so no condensation forms.

More Candy and Easy Dessert Recipes

For a candy with no thermometer, my microwave peanut butter fudge sets in the fridge in an hour, and a few chopped caramels are wonderful stirred into Nutella brownies before they bake. These caramels top my Christmas recipes gift list every year, and there are plenty more quick treats in our easy desserts collection.

Frequently Asked Questions

What temperature do you cook caramel candy to?

Soft, chewy caramels are cooked to the firm-ball stage, 245 to 250°F (118 to 121°C). I pull mine at 245°F for a soft chew and 248°F for a firmer caramel that holds up in gift boxes. Below 240°F they won't hold a shape; above 250°F they turn hard.

Why are my caramels grainy?

Sugar crystals formed in the syrup. The usual causes are stirring the sugar after it starts boiling, sugar crystals left on the pan sides, or skipping the corn syrup. Dissolve the sugar fully, brush the sides with a wet pastry brush, and don't stir until the cream goes in.

Why are my caramels too soft or runny?

They came off the heat before 245°F, or the thermometer reads high. Check it in boiling water. You can rescue a soft batch: scrape it back into the pan with 2 tablespoons of cream, bring it back to a boil and cook to 246°F, then pour it into the lined pan again.

Why are my caramels hard?

They cooked past 250°F, or sat on the heat after the thermometer hit the target. Even 5 degrees makes a difference. Hard caramels are not wasted: melt them with a splash of cream for caramel sauce, or chop them and bake them into cookies and brownies.

Can I make caramels without corn syrup?

Yes, but graininess is more likely. Replace the corn syrup with the same amount of golden syrup or honey, and add 1/4 teaspoon of cream of tartar to the sugar to discourage crystals. Honey browns faster, so watch the color closely in the first stage.

How do you make salted caramels?

Make the recipe as written, then sprinkle 1 teaspoon of flaky sea salt over the caramel as soon as it is poured into the pan, before it skins over. For salt all the way through, increase the fine salt in the cream to 1 teaspoon and still finish with flakes on top.

How long do homemade caramels last?

Wrapped in wax paper and kept in an airtight container at cool room temperature, they stay soft for about 2 weeks. In the fridge they keep for a month; bring them to room temperature before eating. They also freeze well for 3 months, wrapped and sealed in a bag.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*